About Town visits Burning Tree Smokehouse near Pepper Place for a barbecue review.
Owned by local BBQ veteran Warren Webster, Burning Tree is a casual BBQ spot affiliated with the Fatback Pig Project, a pork farm and processing plant owned by Fresh Hospitality Group. If the name sounds familiar, they’re the group behind Taziki’s, Martin’s, Biscuit Love and Big Bad Breakfast. As the Fatback Pig Project developed its new Birmingham processing facility, the team saw an opportunity to turn some of the extra space into a restaurant, giving rise to Burning Tree Smokehouse. At the helm is Warren Webster, a seasoned barbecue professional who spent 35 years honing his pitmaster skills at Jim ’N Nick’s Bar-B-Q before bringing his experience to this new venture.
The Atmosphere
The atmosphere is part of the experience here. The decor has a casual, unfussy feel that suits a smokehouse, creating a comfortable place to settle in for lunch or dinner without worrying about dressing up or making an occasion out of it. The outdoor seating is an especially appealing feature, offering an opportunity to enjoy a meal in the open air when Birmingham’s weather cooperates. Whether you’re meeting friends, grabbing a bite with family or simply in the mood for barbecue, the setting lends itself to an easygoing meal.
The Food & Drink
Of course, atmosphere only goes so far at a barbecue restaurant. The real test is the meat, and the beef brisket at Burning Tree is worth the trip. Our Southeastern pork bias, has meant finding good local beef brisket is not so easy. Their brisket’s bark is one of its best features. That dark, flavorful exterior is an important part of good smoked brisket, adding texture and a concentrated smoky character that contrasts with the softer meat underneath.At Burning Tree, the bark provides a welcome bite and helps give the brisket some personality. It’s the sort of detail barbecue enthusiasts appreciate because it shows that the outside of the meat deserves as much attention as the inside. The brisket comes across as salty, and that saltiness can become more noticeable as you work your way through the portion. Salt is an essential component of barbecue seasoning, helping bring out the meat’s natural flavor, but the balance matters. Here, a lighter hand would allow more of the brisket’s beefy character to shine through. We asked for some hot sauce, and got their habanero sauce. Despite the name, however, don’t expect an especially fiery kick, which many people will like. The sauce doesn’t deliver the level of heat its habanero label might lead some diners to anticipate. Those who prefer milder condiments may appreciate that restraint, while serious heat seekers will probably want something with more punch. It’s a useful reminder that a sauce can carry a pepper’s name without necessarily bringing the intensity associated with it.
The sides are crowd pleasers, but nothing too memorable. Coleslaw, fries, baked beans were all sampled. The barbecue pork sandwich is another option for those who want something a little different from the brisket. Pulled pork is a staple of any serious smokehouse menu, and a good sandwich should deliver plenty of smoky pork flavor in an easy-to-eat package. One consideration is the fat content of the pulled pork. The meat can be a bit fatty, which contributes richness but may leave some diners wishing for a leaner, more evenly balanced serving.
The Parking

enough. Not a problem. It’s over near Lakeview, so street parking is easy
The Bottom Line
Come for the beef brisket. It’s a standout in Birmingham. But the pulled pork was a bit fatty. 2/5 stars Pretty Good
For more Birmingham stories and local recommendations, Sign up for the About Town email.



